Would Mommy Rather
Introduction
Baby showers in the U.S. aren’t just about unwrapping gifts or passing around cupcakes they’re about celebrating new life with laughter, love, and a bit of playful chaos. And let’s be honest, the games are what make them come alive. They’re the part of the day where strangers loosen up, friends turn competitive, and everyone gets a story to tell later.
If you’re after a game that’s both funny and surprisingly heartwarming, try Would Mommy Rather? It’s the baby shower twist on the classic “Would You Rather?” game, except all the questions are about the mom-to-be. Picture guests debating whether she’d rather get unlimited coffee or one solid night of sleep half the fun is in the arguments, and the reveals usually spark even more laughs.
This one’s a keeper because it feels personal, silly, and memorable all at once.
What You’ll Need
- Question cards or printables Make your own in Canva/Word, or grab a ready-made set from Etsy or Amazon.
- Answer sheet for Mommy She fills this out secretly before the game starts.
- Pens or pencils One per guest.
- Prizes Always a fun motivator.
- Optional extras Clipboards, cute stationery, or themed paper to match your décor.
- Affordable, simple, and zero stress to set up.
How to Play
- Here’s the step-by-step:
- Prep the questions. Pick 10-15 lighthearted prompts that fit Mommy’s personality.
- Get Mommy’s answers. Ask her beforehand and keep them secret.
- Hand out sheets. Guests jot down their guesses for what she picked.
- Reveal the answers. The host reads out Mommy’s real choices. This is where the laughs happen.
- Score it. The guest with the most matches wins.
- Hand out a prize. Bonus points if it’s something funny that Mommy would “rather” have herself.
- Players: Works for any group size.
- Time: 15-20 minutes depending on how many questions you use.
Fun Variations
Co-ed version Make it Would Mommy and Daddy Rather? and compare answers. The disagreements are comedy gold.
Kid-friendly twist If kids are at the shower, make it extra goofy. Ask things like, “Would Mommy rather eat ice cream for breakfast or spaghetti for dessert?” The sillier, the better.
Virtual edition Throwing the shower online? Easy fix. Email out a game sheet ahead of time, then have everyone fill it out and reveal the answers together over Zoom. The reactions are just as fun on screen.
Rapid-fire round Skip the writing and go verbal guests shout out answers lightning-fast.
Theme-based version Tie the questions to your shower theme. Tropical party? “Would Mommy rather sip a mocktail on the beach or nap in a hammock?”
Why Guests Love It
- This game works because it’s:
- Personal. Guests learn something new about Mommy.
- Interactive. Everyone participates no one’s left sitting out.
- Funny. The wrong guesses often get the biggest laughs.
- Memorable. Mommy gets to keep the answers as a fun keepsake.
- Effortless. No big props or complicated rules.
- Compared to some of the overdone shower games, this one feels fresh, modern, and genuinely fun.
Conclusion
Baby showers are supposed to be full of joy, laughter, and connection and the right game makes all the difference.
Would Mommy Rather? is one of those rare games that’s personal without being too serious, funny without being awkward, and easy to play without much setup. Guests walk away with stories, inside jokes, and maybe a few surprises about Mommy herself.
So, when you’re planning your shower, add this one to the lineup. It’s quick, affordable, and guaranteed to have the whole room laughing.
🌼 Explore Our Baby Shower Games Collection
Explore a variety of sweet, funny, and unforgettable baby shower games to make your celebration shine!