How Many Cuties In Jar

Introduction

What You’ll Need

1. One reason this game is such a favorite? It’s ridiculously easy to set up. A few everyday items are all it takes, and before you know it, you’ve got a baby shower activity that everyone can join in on.
2. The beauty of this game is how simple it is to pull together. You don’t need fancy props or a long shopping list just a handful of basic supplies, and you’re all set to play.A few simple supplies, and you’re ready to go:
3. A clear container Pick something that fits your vibe. A big mason jar, a glass vase, a punch bowl, or even an oversized baby bottle all work perfectly. The more visible the items inside, the more fun the guessing game becomes.
4. The fillers Traditionally, people use little cutie oranges (hence the name), but don’t feel limited to that! Pacifiers, candy, mini diapers, baby socks, safety pins, marshmallows the options are endless. Choose something that matches your shower’s theme or adds a playful twist.
5. Don’t forget the basics: make sure there are plenty of slips of paper and pens on hand so every guest can jot down their guess. Nobody wants to be waiting around for a pen to free up, so set out more than you think you’ll need.
6. 💡 Want to make the game pop? Dress up your container so it’s more than just a jar on a table. Wrap it with ribbons, stick on a few baby-themed decals, or add a cute little sign that says “Take a guess!” Guests will spot it the moment they walk in, and it immediately sets a playful tone.

How to Play

1. This game only works if you know the answer. Take a few minutes before the shower to count exactly how many items are going into your container. Don’t rush it double-count if you need to. Trust me, nothing feels worse than standing in front of a room full of guests and realizing you don’t actually know the number.
2. Once you’re confident in the total, write it down. Slip the note into an envelope, hide it in your bag, or tape it under the jar anywhere you won’t forget. That little step keeps you from fumbling later when everyone’s waiting for the answer.
3. Want to build some early buzz? Put the jar out on display before the game begins. Guests will walk by, tilt their heads, and throw out random guesses to each other: “No way it’s less than 200!” or “I’m telling you, I’ve got the eye for this.” Half the fun is watching them strategize (or overthink) before they ever write anything down.
4. Place the container where everyone can see it on the gift table, near the food, or in the center of the room so it naturally draws attention.
5. Set out slips of paper and pens beside it. Encourage guests to take a good look and jot down how many items they think are inside.
6. Collect the guesses once everyone’s had their turn. You can drop them in a basket, a decorated box, or even another jar to keep it tidy.
7. Save the reveal for later in the shower. Building suspense makes the announcement way more fun.
8. When it’s time to announce the results, the winner is the person who guessed the exact number. If nobody nails it, the closest guess takes the prize. Either way, the game always brings laughs, groans, and a few “I was so close!” moments.
9. Keep it simple and a little theatrical. Many hosts save the reveal for the end of the shower so everyone crowds around, full of anticipation (and maybe a slice of cake), which makes the moment feel special. If you prefer low-key, announce the winner when most people are nearby either way, build a tiny bit of suspense and enjoy the reactions.
10. For a prize, go practical or playful: a $10–$25 gift card, a cozy candle, a cute mug, a little self-care set, or a whimsical baby-themed trinket (think tiny bibs, novelty pacifiers, or a fun enamel pin). Want more laughs? Give a consolation prize to the person with the wildest guess it gets extra chuckles and makes more people feel included.
11. If two guests tie, break it with something quick and fair: a tiebreaker question (e.g., “How many pieces of candy are in this mini jar?”), or use the “closest without going over” rule, or simply award the prize to the guest who turned in their paper first.

Fun Variations

Why Guests Love It

1. Because it’s wonderfully simple. No complicated rules, no long explanations just a jar, some guesses, and a room full of people making wild estimates. It sparks instant conversation (“No way that many?”), gets groups laughing together, and gives everyone from aunties to coworkers an easy way to join the fun.
2. Plus, it’s flexible. You can play it with practically anything, which means it fits every theme and vibe. Use orange cuties for a bright, playful look; mini diapers for something on-theme and practical; or candy if you want a sweet touch.

Conclusion