✍️ Best Baby Shower Games Editorial Team · Updated May 2026
Lactation Cookie Bake-Off
Ask every guest to bring a dozen homemade lactation cookies and the recipe. The mom-to-be tastes them all, picks her favorite, and walks out the door with a freezer's worth of postpartum snacks. The most genuinely useful game on the list.
- 💝 Sentimental
- 🤝 Low-pressure
- ⏱ Prep
- none
- 👥 Best for
- 5–12 guests
- 🍷 Coed
- Better not
- 📹 Virtual
- In person
What you'll need
- Each guest brings one dozen homemade lactation cookies in a labeled container
- A 4x6 kraft recipe card per guest — Michaels carries 50-packs for $5
- Small disposable bamboo plates from Target for tasting (about $6 a pack)
- Six to eight freezer-safe Ziploc gallon bags for the mom-to-be to take cookies home
- Index cards numbered 1–10 to label each plate at the tasting table
- A small prize for the winner ($25 William Sonoma gift card or a baking kit)
Before the shower (setup)
- The lactation cookie bake-off baby shower game's setup is mostly in the RSVP. Two weeks before the shower, message every guest with the assignment: bring a dozen homemade lactation cookies and write the recipe on a card. Mention the key galactagogue ingredients (oats, brewer's yeast, flax, fenugreek) and ask them to flag any nut or dairy allergies. Coordinate so you don't end up with eight oatmeal-chocolate-chip plates and zero variety — assign a flavor category to anyone repeating.
- Buy the supplies at Target the day before — bamboo plates, kraft recipe cards, numbered index cards, freezer Ziplocs. Check with the mom-to-be first about her allergies and food aversions (first trimester especially). If she can't stomach coconut or peanut butter, tell guests up front. The whole point is that she enjoys this.
- Morning of the shower, set up a tasting table along one wall. Put a small plate down for every guest with their name on the back. Place the recipe card behind the plate so the mom-to-be can flip it over after tasting. Number the plates 1–10. Stack Ziploc bags and a sharpie at the end of the table — she'll pack the leftovers herself when the game wraps.
How to play
About midway through the shower, gather everyone around the tasting table and announce the lactation cookie bake-off baby shower game. Pour everyone a glass of milk or water for palate cleansing. The mom-to-be sits at the head, the rest of the guests stand or sit nearby. Walk her through one plate at a time — guests take a bite alongside her so it doesn't feel like she's being watched eat.
She tastes each cookie, asks the baker a quick question ("what's in this?" or "how long does it bake?"), and writes a 1–10 score on her own scorecard. Don't reveal scores out loud — the bakers don't need to know that grandma's recipe scored a 6. Move through all the plates in 20 minutes. Keep one plate uneaten as a control sample so she can pack a full dozen of every recipe.
When all 10 plates are tasted, the mom-to-be steps aside for two minutes to total scores, then announces her winner. The winning baker gets a small named prize. The mom-to-be packs every leftover cookie into the Ziploc bags, labels each one with the baker's name and recipe number, and takes the whole haul home — her postpartum stash for weeks two through six.
Variations to try
- Postpartum freezer meal swap. Trade cookies for full freezer-ready dinners. Each guest brings one labeled, freezable meal (lasagna, soup, chili). Less photogenic, more useful. Works beautifully for second-baby showers where snacks aren't the bottleneck.
- Mocktail and cookie pairing. Pair every cookie with a custom mocktail from [[mocktail-mixology-contest]]. Guests bring both, the mom-to-be scores the pairing. Combined food block runs about 60 minutes.
- Postpartum mom panel. If the mom-to-be has food aversions or doesn't want to be the sole judge, switch to a three-person panel — three friends who've nursed a baby in the last two years. They score on taste, texture, and actually-want-to-eat-this-at-3am factor.
- Generic cookie bake-off. If lactation cookies feel too niche or the crowd is split coed, run a plain cookie bake-off with no theme. Same setup, no galactagogue rule. Often a better fit for office or coed showers.
- Add-on: recipe book. Collect every recipe card and slide them into a small kraft-paper photo album from Michaels. The mom-to-be takes home an instant cookbook of every recipe from her shower.
Pro tips from hosts who've actually run this
- Coordinate flavors in the RSVP. Without it you'll get five oatmeal-chocolate-chip plates and the tasting feels flat.
- Pre-label every container with the baker's name and a number. Without labels the postpartum stash becomes a mystery pile.
- Use bamboo plates, not paper. Paper plates wilt under warm cookies and the photos look messy.
- Pour milk or water in small cups for palate cleansing. After plate 4 every cookie starts tasting the same.
- Don't read scores out loud. The bakers want to feel good about contributing — not ranked publicly.
- Skip if the mom-to-be has gestational diabetes or any dietary restriction. Check with her three weeks out, not three days.
- Save 2 cookies from every plate before tasting begins. That way the mom-to-be's freezer stash isn't picked over by the guests.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Forgetting to coordinate the flavor categories. Without RSVP coordination you'll end up with duplicate recipes and no variety on the table.
- Skipping the recipe cards. Without cards, the postpartum stash is anonymous cookies in a freezer — useless when she wants to recreate her favorite.
- Letting guests serve cookies still warm. They taste different at room temperature; bake the night before and let them cool.
- Forgetting allergy checks. One peanut butter cookie at a shower where the mom-to-be is dairy-free wrecks the whole event.
- Letting the tasting drag past 25 minutes. The mom-to-be hits flavor fatigue fast — keep it tight or her scores stop being honest.
Best prize for this game
Lean into baking-themed prizes. A $25 King Arthur Baking gift card, a Williams Sonoma cookie scoop and cooling rack set, or a fancy Le Creuset mixing bowl all hit the right note. A $20 Trader Joe's gift card with a tin of fancy chocolate chips works for a more budget-friendly option. Wrap it in a kraft paper bag with a small tag — visible, named, and clearly the prize.
Our verdict
The lactation cookie bake-off baby shower game does double duty — it's a real bake-off and a postpartum gift the mom-to-be will reach for at 2 a.m. in week four. Niche, but unforgettable.
Lactation Cookie Bake-Off — FAQ
Do lactation cookies actually help with milk supply?
The evidence is mixed. The galactagogue ingredients (oats, brewer's yeast, flax, fenugreek) are gentle and harmless, and many nursing parents swear by them anecdotally. The bigger benefit during postpartum is calorie density — they're easy snacks during nighttime feeds. Either way, they're safe and useful.
How many cookies should each guest bring to the lactation cookie bake-off?
One dozen. The mom-to-be tastes 1–2 from each plate; the rest goes into her postpartum freezer stash. With 10 guests that's 100 cookies — roughly 4–6 weeks of midnight snacks at one or two per feed.
Is the Lactation Cookie Bake-Off good for a coed baby shower?
It can work, but it tilts toward female friends and family who've nursed before. For a coed shower, run [[mocktail-mixology-contest]] or [[candy-bar-name-game]] alongside so the dads-to-be and friends without baking interest still have something to do.
How long does the lactation cookie bake-off baby shower game take?
Plan for 30 minutes total — 20 minutes of tasting and scoring, 10 minutes of voting, prize-giving, and packing up the postpartum stash. Shorter than that and the mom-to-be can't score honestly; longer and palate fatigue ruins the round.
Can pregnant women eat lactation cookies safely?
Yes, the ingredients are pregnancy-safe — oats, flax, brewer's yeast, fenugreek are all common in pregnancy diets. The actual milk-supply benefit only kicks in postpartum. If the mom-to-be has gestational diabetes, ask the host to swap in sugar-free versions or skip the game entirely.
What's the best prize for the Lactation Cookie Bake-Off?
A baking-themed gift makes sense — a $25 King Arthur gift card, a Williams Sonoma cookie scoop set, or a Le Creuset mixing bowl. A $20 Trader Joe's gift card with a tin of fancy chocolate chips is a great budget option.
Similar baby shower games
-
Baby Word Scramble →
A sheet of scrambled letters that spell baby words — RDIEPA for diaper, ARTLET for rattle, RBETOTLO for bottle. Set a timer for four minutes and whoever unscrambles the most wins. Fastest, cheapest game to fill a quiet stretch between food and gifts.
-
Guess the Due Date & Stats →
Each guest writes down their guess for the baby's birth date, weight, length, and a few other stats on a prediction card. After the baby arrives, the parents pick the closest guess and mail the winner a small prize. The cards double as a keepsake the parents can frame.
-
Advice Cards for the New Parents →
Set up a small "advice station" near the entry. Each guest writes one piece of parenting advice on a card — funny, serious, or somewhere in between — and drops it in a box. The mom-to-be takes the box home as their first parenting manual, and re-reads them at 3 a.m. for the next year.
-
Decorate a Onesie →
Set up a craft station with plain white onesies, fabric markers, and stencils. Each guest decorates one onesie. After the shower, the host iron-sets the designs so they survive the wash — and the baby actually wears every single one during the first six months.
Browse by category
About the author
Best Baby Shower Games Editorial Team — Party planners, parents & writers. We’re a small team of party planners and parents who’ve hosted — and been guests at — dozens of baby showers. Every game here is sorted by what actually lands in a real room, not by what just looks cute on a Pinterest board.