✍️ Best Baby Shower Games Editorial Team · Updated May 2026
Baby Cupcake Decorating Contest
Set out plain cupcakes, three colors of frosting in piping bags, and a tray of sprinkles, candy eyes, and mini fondant pieces. Each guest decorates 1–2 cupcakes to look like a baby item — pacifier, bottle, tiny face, stork. The mom-to-be picks her favorite, the winner takes a prize, and everyone eats the artwork.
- 🧒 Kid-friendly
- ✅ Crowd-pleaser
- 🤝 Low-pressure
- 🌀 A bit messy
- ⏱ Prep
- 30 min+
- 👥 Best for
- 6–18 guests
- 🍷 Coed
- Yes
- 📹 Virtual
- In person
What you'll need
- 30 plain vanilla cupcakes — bake from a Betty Crocker box mix or order from Costco the day before ($24 for 30)
- Three pre-tinted frosting colors in disposable piping bags — Wilton kit from Michaels or Hobby Lobby ($10)
- Sprinkle tray — pastel pearls, jimmies, and edible silver sugar pearls from Target's baking aisle
- A jar of Wilton candy eyes and a small pack of pastel fondant pieces from Hobby Lobby
- Twelve pop-up parchment squares as decorating mats and a stack of wet wipes
- Small disposable cake stands or cardboard cake rounds from Walmart for the finished display
Before the shower (setup)
- Plan the baby cupcake decorating contest baby shower game two days out. Bake or order 30 plain vanilla cupcakes — Costco's 30-pack and Trader Joe's frozen vanilla cupcakes both work. Don't bother with chocolate; pale frosting reads better against a vanilla cupcake. Stop by Michaels or Hobby Lobby for a Wilton piping bag kit, the candy eyes jar, and a small pack of pastel fondant. Target's baking aisle has every sprinkle you'll need.
- The morning of the shower, tint three batches of buttercream — soft pink, mint green, pale yellow — and load each into a disposable piping bag with a round tip. Buttercream from a Betty Crocker tub works fine; one tub fills two bags. Skip cream cheese frosting and skip anything labeled "summer-stable" — in a warm room buttercream looks softer and pipes cleaner.
- Set up the decorating station along a long table, food side. Front row: a tray of 30 cupcakes on disposable cake stands. Middle row: the three piping bags, parchment squares as mats, a stack of small offset spatulas. Back row: sprinkle jars, candy eyes, fondant pieces, a wet-wipe pile. Decorate one demo cupcake yourself — a pacifier, say, or a sleepy baby face — and place it front and center so guests have a starting point.
How to play
About 45 minutes into the shower, gather guests around the table and announce the baby cupcake decorating contest baby shower game. Each guest takes a parchment square, picks 1 or 2 plain cupcakes, and decorates them to look like a baby-themed object — pacifier, baby bottle, sleepy face, tiny diaper, baby chick, onesie shape, stork. Give 15 minutes. Set a timer.
While guests pipe and sprinkle, the kid table in the corner is usually the most creative — let them go. The mom-to-be either plays alongside everyone or sits at the head of the table judging. Wet wipes get passed around constantly; the parchment mats stop the table from looking like a Hobby Lobby explosion by the end. Take photos every 5 minutes — the half-decorated cupcakes are the funniest shots of the day.
When the timer rings, line every finished cupcake up on a cake stand or cardboard round. The mom-to-be walks the line, picks her favorite (and one runner-up — there's always a tie). Announce the winner, hand the prize, and let everyone dig in. Save a couple of the prettiest ones for the dessert table photo — those are the cupcakes that end up in the shower album.
Variations to try
- Sugar cookies instead. Swap cupcakes for plain sugar cookies. Sturdier, easier to design intricate shapes, and they don't smush in transit. Order pre-baked cookies from Walmart's bakery for $10 a dozen.
- Theme round. Limit the round to one shape — only animals, only baby items, only foods. Tighter scope makes the round more competitive. Best for adult-only crowds where everyone's piping skills are similar.
- Solo bake-off. Skip the at-the-shower station entirely. Ask 6 guests to each bring half a dozen pre-decorated cupcakes. The mom-to-be picks the winner. Pairs beautifully with [[lactation-cookie-bake-off]] for a back-to-back food block.
- Diaper-cake-decorating combo. Pair with [[diaper-cake-decorating]] for a craft station with one edible decorating game and one non-edible centerpiece. Guests rotate. Works for 90-minute showers.
- Kid-led round. If the shower has kids ages 4+, let them lead. The adult guests provide encouragement and pipe difficult details. The mom-to-be picks her favorite — but every kid gets a prize. Wonderful for cousins-heavy showers.
Pro tips from hosts who've actually run this
- Pre-color and bag the frosting the night before. Loading piping bags at the shower wastes 20 minutes guests would rather spend decorating.
- Parchment squares as decorating mats save your tablecloth. They're $4 at Walmart for a 100-pack.
- Make one demo cupcake yourself. Without a visual reference, three guests will freeze at the table.
- Skip buttercream in summer if the shower is outdoor. Use Swiss meringue frosting or order pre-decorated bases.
- Use round piping tips for everything. Star tips are pretty but harder to control for non-bakers.
- Take a group photo of every cupcake on the cake stand before judging. That's the photo every shower group shares afterward.
- Keep wet wipes within arm's reach. Sticky fingers ruin the sprinkle jar in 90 seconds flat.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Buying chocolate cupcakes. Dark cake makes pastel frosting look murky in photos — vanilla wins every time.
- Skipping the demo cupcake. Without an example, guests stare at the materials for a full minute before starting.
- Putting frosting in plastic spreaders, not piping bags. Spreaders give a flat, messy look; piping bags read clean and crafted.
- Forgetting allergy coordination. At least one guest will be gluten-free or dairy-free — order a small batch of GF cupcakes from Whole Foods or Trader Joe's to cover them.
- Letting the round drag past 20 minutes. The kids and the buttercream both wilt fast. Tight time-boxing keeps the game energetic.
Best prize for this game
Lean into baking-and-sweets prizes. A $20 Williams Sonoma gift card, a Wilton cake-decorating kit from Michaels ($25), a Yankee Candle vanilla-cupcake-scented candle, or a $20 Trader Joe's gift card with a small chocolate sampler. Wrap it on the decorating table from the start so guests see what they're competing for.
Our verdict
The baby cupcake decorating contest baby shower game doubles as dessert. Easy to run, photogenic, and the kid table in the corner will out-decorate the adults every single time.
Baby Cupcake Decorating Contest — FAQ
How do I run a baby cupcake decorating contest baby shower game?
Set up a station with 30 plain vanilla cupcakes, three colors of buttercream in piping bags, sprinkles, candy eyes, and fondant. Each guest decorates 1–2 cupcakes to look like a baby item. The mom-to-be picks her favorite, and the winner takes a prize. Total game time is about 30–40 minutes.
How many cupcakes should I prep for the contest?
Two per guest plus 4–6 spares. For 15 guests that's about 34 cupcakes; round up to 36 from Costco's 30-pack plus a 6-pack from Trader Joe's. Plain vanilla beats chocolate for photo color.
How long does the baby cupcake decorating contest take?
Plan for 30–40 minutes — 15 minutes of decorating, 10 of voting and prize-giving, and another 15 of eating. Set a 15-minute timer on the decorating phase or guests will keep tinkering past the moment that matters.
Can kids play the cupcake decorating game at a baby shower?
Yes — and they usually win. Kids ages 4 and up love this game and their cupcakes are often the most creative on the table. If the shower has a lot of children, run the kid-led variation where every child gets a small prize regardless of who the mom-to-be picks as the winner.
What about food allergies?
Coordinate with the mom-to-be and guests three weeks before. Order 4–6 gluten-free or dairy-free cupcakes from Whole Foods or Trader Joe's to cover any allergies. Label the GF/DF tray separately so guests know which is which.
Is the cupcake decorating contest good for a coed baby shower?
Yes — it's one of the easier coed baby shower games. The dads-to-be lean in once they see the sprinkles. Skip overly delicate designs and give them simple shapes like baby bottles or footprints to pipe.
Similar baby shower games
-
Baby Food Taste Test →
Line up 6 to 8 jars of baby food with the labels hidden. Guests taste each one, write their flavor guess on a sheet, and the most correct identifications wins. The face every guest makes when they hit the prunes is half the entertainment.
-
Don’t Drop the Baby Relay →
Two teams race a stand-in "baby" — a hard-boiled egg balanced on a spoon, a water balloon cradled in two hands, or a baby doll held against the chest — from start to finish. Drop it mid-run and your team starts the leg over. First team through wins.
-
Diaper Mummy Wrap Race →
Each team picks one volunteer and races to wrap them head-to-ankle in toilet paper like a giant diaper. Fastest, fullest, most creative wrap wins — judged by the mom-to-be. The post-game photos are the entire reason anyone plays.
-
Match the Baby Socks →
A pile of twenty-four tiny mismatched baby socks. Two minutes on the clock. Race to sort them into pairs. The grandmother in the corner secretly wins this every time — she's been doing laundry for forty years.
Browse by category
About the author
Best Baby Shower Games Editorial Team — Party planners, parents & writers. We’re a small team of party planners and parents who’ve hosted — and been guests at — dozens of baby showers. Every game here is sorted by what actually lands in a real room, not by what just looks cute on a Pinterest board.